"The Valley of Decision"

Author: Marcia Davenport

Genre: Historical Fiction

Publisher: University of Pittsburgh Press, 1989

Pages: 640

My Rating: Highly Recommend

Valley of Decision transports the reader back in time to when Pittsburgh was an industry hub.

Synopsis: On the eve of World War II  writer Marcia Davenport, best known for her biography of Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, spent several years in Pittsburgh, her imagination caught by the drama of American industry.  In 1942, Charles Scribner’s sons published her Pittsburgh novel, The Valley of Decision.  It was an instant success, and its story of four generations of the Scott family - owners and operators of a Pittsburgh iron and steel works - has captured the imagination of three generations of readers.

The story is absorbing and complex, chronicling the family fortunes from the economic panic of 1873 through the dramatic rise of American industry and trade unionism, though waves of immigration, class conflict, natural disaster, World War I, to Pearl Harbor.

The first portion of the narrative covers the period 1873-83, when ironmaster William Scott, founder of the Scott Iron Works, marched with American industrial progress and died at the hands of union agitators.  The second section covers 1889-1929 and his son Paul, who inherits the mills and manages them well, embracing technology, the demands of the first World War, and an enlightened view of labor.  Part Three (1933-41) is the book of Claire, great-granddaughter of William.  Energetic, responsible, and worldy-wise, she fights to save the integrity of the family’s mills as they pass into the hands of corporation lawyers and bored Scott cousins.  It is also Claire who expands the story to Eastern Europe, where, as an international journalist, she brings the horrifying events leading to World War II to the attention of an impassive America.

But the central character in the Scott family saga is Mary Rafferty, an Irish maid who, as the novel opens, enters the Scott household at the age of sixteen.  Her sixty-eight years of service to the Scotts span the growth of the family’s mills and the vicissitudes of individual family members.  Mary is an advisor and trusted equal of the younger generations of Scotts, particularly Paul, for whom she is a driving force and lifelong love.  Mary sees beyond her station, perceptive in ways the wealthy Scotts are not.  Her unswerving loyalty to them, and her fierce independence from them, make her the core and the conscience of the family and of the book.

Review: This book is a real treat. There's great character development and a solid storyline. I've read this several times and it just gets better with each reading. Expect to become emotionally vested. The Valley of Decision is set in Pittsburgh at a time when the city was a focal point for industry in the United States (and around the world); locals will find it particularly enjoyable.

Note: Barnes and Noble lists this as a textbook on their website. It is not a textbook. I promise.